Google loses 'right to be forgotten' case

Individual privacy vs. public good gets its day in court

A businessman fighting for the "right to be forgotten" on Google has won his "unprecedented" High Court action against the tech giant.

Both men demanded that Google remove search results mentioning the cases for which they were convicted.

The company's representative, Antony White QC, said that the ruling was "not a right to rewrite history or. tailor your past if that's what this claimant would like to use it for".

Some 669,355 requests for links to be removed from the search engine results have been made to Google since the ruling.

The businessman who lost his case had complained about three links returned by Google providing information about his conviction for "conspiracy to account falsely", for which he received a sentence of four years. "There is no real need for anybody to be warned about that activity". The businessman was involved in a multi-million pound fraud.

Granting an appeal in the case of NT1, the judge added: "It is quite likely that there will be more claims of this kind, and the fact that NT2 has succeeded is likely to reinforce that".

Under English law created to rehabilitate offenders, those convictions don't have to be disclosed to potential employers and can effectively be ignored.

"The Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 sought to strike a balance on this thorny topic". "That held good until the internet and Google's powerful search engine rather undid matters".

House catches fire in Chesapeake, leaves four displaced
The Athens City Fire Department responded to the fire in the 700 block of East Madison Avenue just after 8:15 pm. The Midland County Volunteer Fire Department says they are aren't taking any chances the next two days.

Police called to hospital protest for terminally ill boy Alfie Evans
The judge described Alfie's life as "profoundly unfair" but accepted medical evidence that showed further treatment was futile. They hope that specialists at Rome's Bambino Gesu Paediatric Hospital will be able to pinpoint what is wrong with their child.

Elon Musk Says Tesla Will Be Profitable By Third Quarter
In a statement emailed to NPR, a Tesla spokesperson said the company chose to withdraw from the agreement of its own accord. BidaskClub raised shares of Tesla from a "sell" rating to a "hold" rating in a research note on Wednesday, January 31st.

"The Court will have to balance the public's right to access the historical record, the precise impacts on the person, and the public interest".

"The crime and punishment information has become out of date, irrelevant and of no sufficient legitimate interest to users of Google Search to justify its continued availability, so that an appropriate delisting order should be made", Justice Warby of the High Court said, The Telegraph reported.

The Right to Be Forgotten can be interpreted in various ways by courts throughout Europe.

The judges said the right to privacy should prevail after laying down a series of benchmarks including impact on work and family life that dictated whether results should be easily available.

"Given his family situation, the loss of his job would cause him a very serious prejudice, especially given that it took him almost two years to find a new job", the judges said.

"He remains in business, and the information serves the objective of minimizing the risk that he will continue to mislead, as he has in the past", the court said. Plus, since he "remains in business", the information remains relevant to the public. Others, however, expressed concern that the ruling could harm free press and speech rights.

As Engadget noted, the London high court ruling could force internet companies to not immediately dismiss conviction-related delisting requests.

Related News:

  • Child's Body Found Along NorCal River In Search For Missing Family

    The California Highway Patrol developed information this family were traveling in a family vehicle, a 2016 maroon Honda Pilot. The family was reported missing on April 8 by a relative in San Jose who had expected them to arrive two days earlier.
    Paul Ryan and the Exodus of Republicans From Congress

    Paul Ryan and the Exodus of Republicans From Congress

    Some will say that the Senate is all the matters at this point. "We need more minorities and more women in our party", he said. Swan and Allen said a senior GOP House member predicted, "He will be gone by the end of July".
    'Incredibles 2' trailer features Elastigirl at the center of the

    'Incredibles 2' trailer features Elastigirl at the center of the

    Nelson, and Sarah Powell voicing their super-powered alter-egos. " Incredibles 2 " will be released nationwide June 15 . Jackson ) must find a way to work together again-which is easier said than done, even when they're all Incredible .
  • Commonwealth Games: India's men's hockey team loses to New Zealand in semis

    Commonwealth Games: India's men's hockey team loses to New Zealand in semis

    In other Gold Coast action, Mauchline badminton star Adam Hall and his men's doubles partner Alex Dunn reached the quarter-finals. Which means that the bronze medal she collected today was well earned, even if it was quite bizarre.and a little bit lucky.
    Dad in incest case killed daughter, infant son and adoptive father

    Dad in incest case killed daughter, infant son and adoptive father

    Before Katie moved into Alyssa and Steven's Henrico home, she lived in NY with her adoptive parents, Kelly and Anthony Fusco. It is the same home where Steven Pladl and Katie Pladl lived when they were charged with having an incestuous relationship.
    OnePlus 6 front has a notch

    OnePlus 6 front has a notch

    OnePlus may choose to implement voice commands and support for Google Assistant to offer a seamless experience to listeners. Company OnePlus has provided a gesture input device on your 5T with the release of Android Oreo Open Beta 3.
  • They will be coming: US President Donald Trump's missile threat to Russian Federation

    They will be coming: US President Donald Trump's missile threat to Russian Federation

    However Mrs May faces growing impatience from Washington , where President Donald Trump tweeted the missiles "will be coming". But she had also made clear the president was holding both Syria and Russian Federation responsible for the attack.

    The gold iPhone X just got exposed

    Last year, another employee was sacked for leaking details about the iPhone X , iPad Pro, and AirPods to 9to5Mac. Not surprisingly, Gurman was also first to report on the leak of the memo , which is reprinted in full below.

    SUV that fell in river belonged to missing OR family

    The items had turned up over the course of searches of the South Fork of the Eel River over the past two days, the statement said. A family of four is missing in California, and authorities fear they may have driven into the Eel River while on a road trip.
  • Tornado watch issued for Denton County

    Tornado watch issued for Denton County

    The strongest action, if it develops, will be between Lawrence and Kansas City through the late afternoon and early evening. Some of the supercell thunderstorms could produce baseball-sized hail, damaging winds and isolated tornadoes.
    UN Secretary-General warns Syria tensions could lead to

    UN Secretary-General warns Syria tensions could lead to "full-blown military escalation"

    The US and France say they have proof it took place and, alongside the United Kingdom , are considering military retaliation. The White House says it is continuing to assess intelligence and talk to its allies about how to respond.
    Offa robbery: Police arrest 12 prime suspects

    Offa robbery: Police arrest 12 prime suspects

    They say the truck was driven to the bank's parking lot at the time of the robbery and was located nearby by police. On Wednesday, police identified the suspect as Andrew Aaron Lamore, 33, of no fixed address.


Most liked

Malaysia's IHH Healthcare tops Manipal Hospital's bid for Fortis
The deal is critical for Manipal to expand its presence in the growing hospitals business beyond south India. Meanwhile a statement from the Fortis Healthcare said that the proposal is under evaluation by the company.

Changing tactics: Cosby defence aggressively attacks accuser
Dickinson is the fourth accuser to take the witness stand at Cosby's sex assault retrial in suburban Philadelphia. She testified that she remembers waking up later to Cosby clapping his hands to her.

Russian embassy rebuffs Pompeo's Moscow intervention accusation
Petersburg-based Internet Research Agency, which ran an online propaganda campaign that allegedly undermined the 2016 polls. The date for the vote confirming Mr Pompeo in the full Senate has not been set but is likely in the coming weeks.

Ecuador president says kidnapped journalists likely killed
Colombia's president, Juan Manuel Santos, has sent top military and police officers to Quito in order to assist with the crisis. Moreno explained that he had asked the Colombian government, army and police to immediately begin these actions.

Woman arrested after claiming she was touched inappropriately by officer
Jordan, who was 35 at the time, was supposed to be on his way home when the call came into headquarters. Jordan suffered a permanent brain injury which left him quadriplegic and in a vegetative state.

Blizzard warnings and watches posted for much of Nebraska
Current weather forecasts predict blizzard conditions in much of Northwest Kansas Friday through Saturday . The K-State Parachute Club 3K Day has also been cancelled for Saturday because of weather conditions.

Peerless Semenya denies Kenya gold in women's 800m
Canada's Alysha Newman set a games record 4.75m to win the pole vault, with a mark 5cm higher than McCartney. South Africa won the first heat with Akani Simbine overtaking Australia over the last 50 meters.

Victor of $533M Mega Millions jackpot comes forward
Mega Millions is played in 44 states plus Washington, D.C., and the U.S. They are also required to participate in a mandatory news conference.

Connecticut Substitute Teacher Gets Sacked for Overseeing Student Fight Club
A 34-year-old teacher moving to an isolated area does not want to share a house with strangers, Professor Halsey said. He has denied directly facilitating the fights and said he thought the students were just being "rambunctious".

Guardiola unsure over length of Aguero injury absence
Gabriel Jesus is expected to start up front in place of Aguero, while Leroy Sane and Raheem Sterling should feature on the wings. Guardiola said: "They are human beings and they are disappointed because they gave it everything but we have to stand up".

Lost In Space 2018 Netflix series - start date, cast and review
After $0.41 actual EPS reported by Netflix, Inc . for the previous quarter, Wall Street now forecasts 53.66 % EPS growth. Among 15 analysts covering Canadian Imperial Bank Of Commerce ( NYSE:CM ), 6 have Buy rating , 2 Sell and 7 Hold.

Kentucky Teachers To Rally Again As Lawmakers Return For Final Legislative Days
Bevin vetoed both bills because he said the new taxes won't generate enough money to cover the new spending. But not rejecting the vetoes means the state government won't have money to operate for the next two years.

Colorado Avalanche vs. Nashville Predators Matchup 4/12/18
MST on Thursday. "The only thing more important than bringing the Cup to Nashville is the safety of our Smashville citizens". They are looking too add another three, as team President Sean Henry explained: 'Good symbolism with those four catfish.

Why Martial is out of favour at Man United
Another team making a strong case for signing Anthony Martial is Manchester United's Premier League rivals Tottenham Hotspur . Also, the resurgence of Jesse Lingard worked against him and the arrival of Alexis Sanchez did not do any good either.

Make Way for Kylie Jenner and Stormi in Their New Fendi Stroller
Kylie Jenner ignores her sister's relationship drama and shows off her post-pregnancy body. She simply captioned the snap with the words, " stormi strolls ".