SCOTUS Sides With Inmate Over Juror's Use of N-Word

The Supreme Court said the juror's statement

The Supreme Court is giving a Georgia death row inmate whose execution was called off a year ago another chance to raise claims of racial bias on his jury.

In a 6-3 ruling on Monday, the highest U.S. court decided that Keith Tharpe, who is black, deserves another chance to appeal his 1990 murder conviction.

The jury member said under oath: "After studying the Bible, I have wondered if black people even have souls". Tharpe is black, and the Supreme Court declared in a 6-3 opinion that juror Barney Gattie's views may have tainted his ability to deliver a fair verdict.

But, the court continued, the affidavit (which the court described as "remarkable") nonetheless "presents a strong factual basis for the argument that Tharpe's race affected" the juror's vote for the death penalty.

The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta probably will reach the same conclusion and deny Tharpe's appeal on other grounds, he wrote, referring to his colleagues' action as a "useless do-over".

On Sept. 25, 1990, Tharpe drove a pickup truck to intercept his estranged wife and her sister in law, Jaquelin Freeman, as they set out for their jobs in Macon.

JBL launches line of around-ear, on-ear, & in-ear headphones w
It is available in Gunmetal Silver, Mountain Silver, and Steel Blue, and the batteries should last about eight hours. There are large passive radiators at the sides of this speaker in order to deliver enhanced bass frequencies.

Porn Star Olivia Nova Found Dead In Las Vegas
In her Twitter bio , Nova said that she was a vegan, a "dog mom", and "Oh year and I like wine so don't try and stop me". Newsweek said Nova, who began her firm work in March 2017, was considered a rising star in the adult fim industry.

Trump signs order expanding mental health benefits for veterans
Use that same number and press "1" to reach the Veterans Crisis Line. That new executive order will go into effect March 9.

Freeman, the murder victim, came from a family of "nice black folks", Gattie said. But the state post-conviction court would not consider any evidence of potential racial bias, and a federal district court also declined to consider that evidence.

Tharpe petitioned to reopen his habeas petition last June, citing new Supreme Court opinions regarding grants for certificate of appealability claims based on extraordinary circumstances.

Thomas said the court was swayed by the "odious" remarks in Gattie's statement, but should have focused on procedural problems with Tharpe's case and the lower court's determination that Tharpe's death sentence did not depend upon racist considerations by the jury. Reportedly, while Tharpe's wife and sister were in a auto, Tharpe blocked them on the road in the truck he was driving. Nearly nothing short of an admission that they hate black people and knew that this defendant was innocent but they railroaded them anyway is good enough to meet that standard.

In dissent, Thomas said the lower courts had properly considered and disposed of Tharpe's claims.

Gattie also maintained he'd been drinking when he signed his first affidavit, Thomas said.

"But the court's decision is no profile in moral courage", he added. But in March of previous year, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the right to a fair trial supersedes such laws when racial animus influenced the verdict or sentence. "The attention to racial discrimination is long overdue because it has always been a factor in many criminal cases and particularly in death penalty cases", he said.

Related News:



Most liked

Behold: the 161mph Fisker EMotion
Production of the EMotion will take place in the U.S. , although the location won't be announced until the second half of 2018. The EMotion is powered by a set of electric motors generating at least 575kW of power, with drive sent to all four wheels.

Bulls forward Nikola Mirotic reportedly 'intrigued' by Utah Jazz
Plus, if the team elects to move on from Derrick Favors after this season, Mirotic could potentially help with that type of blow. Interestingly, the feeling is mutual, as ESPN's Adrian Wojnarowski noted that Mirotic was "intrigued" with the Jazz .

Noble Midstream Partners LP (NYSE:NBLX) Quant Signal & Earnings At a Glance
The company reported $0.02 earnings per share (EPS) for the quarter, missing analysts' consensus estimates of $0.06 by ($0.04). Usca Ria Limited Liability Company holds 0.86% of its portfolio in Verizon Communications Inc. (NYSE:ABBV) for 318,889 shares.

Gopher Basketball Player Could Face Expulsion After Third Assault Allegation
The alleged incident took place in April of 2016, and was investigated last fall after the victim reported it to school officials. Lynch's attorney, Ryan Pacyga, announced on Twitter he would host a press conference to address concerns on Wednesday at 1 p.m.

National Championship Game: Alabama vs
Rodrigo Blankenship stepped up and cooly hit a 51-yard field goal anyway for the 23-20 Georgia lead. The quarterbacks bought in, the team bought in and Tagovailoa rewarded Saban's trust.

Seth Meyers tackles Trump in Golden Globes speech focused on sexual harassment
The tone he set has stayed ever since - opening with a cutting monologue about Hollywood, often mocking numerous stars present. She told E!: "I think people are aware now of a power imbalance and that is something that leads to abuse.

Federal Crackdown Likely Won't Impact Oklahoma Vote on Medicinal Marijuana
Members of Congress have put law enforcement in an awkward spot by looking away as states diverge from federal statute. That would leave it up to each state and its voters to decide whether legalization works for them.

AFL great Mark Thompson released without charge following drug probe
His decorated AFL career includes three premierships during his playing days at Essendon and later coaching Geelong to two flags. He coached Geelong to premierships in 2007 and 2009 before returning to Windy Hill as James Hird's senior coaching assistant.

Luxury Car Sales figures of 2017
The two X-Class concepts are on display at the CMT show, alongside the existing Marco Polo campervan. The increase of more than 25.9% helped Mercedes-Benz to post a new sales record in China.

Ford to Take Orders for First F-150 Diesel Pickup
Ford said they will accept orders for the diesel F-150 beginning this month and deliveries are expected in the spring. But buyers appreciate knowing the all-new diesel delivers the best towing and payload while burning less fuel.

Zidane insists he doesn't want signings despite Madrid 'crisis'
I am aware that I have in front of me great players who listen to me. " I know I won't stay [in the job] for 10 years ". Today, yes, the danger is there, but I will not change", he told France Football to be issued on Tuesday.

Iran's Zarif to meet European Union foreign chief in Brussels
In his weekly press conference, FM spokesman Bahram Ghasemi also maintained that "the meeting will be held at the invitation of Ms.

Texas Tech University Ranked One of the Best Online Engineering Programs
At the undergraduate level, the Fox Online BBA retained its No. 2 national rank, where it was ranked by U.S. News rankings", said Terry Rawls, executive director for Distance Education at Appalachian.

PC / Xbox One Pirate Game Sea Of Thieves Beta Dates Announced
If you reserved the game at retail, you'll first need to redeem the code you received for the Black Dog cosmetic pack. Beginning on January 24th 12PM GMT the closed beta for Sea of Thieves will run until January 29th.

Georgia quarterback Jacob Eason expected to transfer to Washington
According to the Seattle Times , Eason, "barring a last-minute change of heart", will transfer to the University of Washington . This does not come as a surprise based on a series of events that seems likely to push Eason back to third string next season.